The species of the killer whale has been made famous from one of the greatest tourist attractions, Sea World, where the main show consisted of Shamu, the killer whale performing tricks with its trainers. It is amazing that a mammal that can weigh up to eleven tons can be trained to do flips and routines. The largest carnivore on earth has a keen intelligence in the wild that allows them to easily adapt in captivity. They hunt in packs to ensure survival and actually plan their tactics before the kill. Killer whales also have many human-like qualities, which allow people to relate more and think of them more intelligent like humans. They have different dialects depending on which pod or family they are in, and are very inquisitive in nature around new things (Ward). Like humans and their families, killer whales form strong social bonds with the others around them (Sea World). They also have all of the senses that humans have giving them the same opportunity to learn with these senses (Sea World). They learn quickly, obviously allowing them to understand human requests in return for treats. They seem to memorize well and are able to adapt easily in a different aquatic environment than the ocean. The killer whale is in all of these aspects similar to humans. They have similar family life, senses, unique speech, and adaptability patterns, making them seem to be parallel in intelligence.
One species killer whales prey on is emperor penguins, which are seen to be more instinctual. Emperor penguins inhabit one of the harshest places on earth, the tundra of Antarctica. They seem to live their lives all in an instinctual pattern of survival and reproduction. Instead of moving to areas closer to the sea, the females journey great distances while the baby penguin is still in the egg to only journey back in summer. They have no distinct patterns of hunting or feeding and only are sure there are no dangers in the water until one penguin takes the leap into the sea. As seen in the movie Happy Feet, when a food source is scarce, penguins do not know how to relocate to find food, they simply keep with their set plan. Also, penguins do not understand tides. Many penguins get stuck in the water because their ice landing where they entered is higher. Penguins in Antarctica have never had to adapt to a different condition, and often in captivity they do not perform any differently. They are more instinctual and do not seem to be interested in having interactions with different species or humans. Therefore, these birds are seen as more instinctual and less intelligent compared to a mammal like the killer whale.
Although it seems to be true that killer whales are more intelligent than penguins, the main reason these species are seen this way is due to the human response. It is the way that humans interact with these species that ultimately defines whether an animal is intellectual or instinctual. Therefore, the definition of intelligence has to be considered. We have learned that brain size does not define intelligence, and most animals can be trained to do tricks if rewarded with food or another pleasure. The classification of intelligence depends on how much humans understand the animal and its environment. As stated before, humans have been working with killer whales at places such as Sea World for years. They have been able to take one of the largest mammals and train them to perform routines consisting of flips and leaps. Because they adapt well to the environment in captivity, and because we can research them more, we know more about their abilities and deem them more intelligent. However, we hardly ever seem to work with emperor penguins, especially outside of their environment. We only see their march, the journey they take to retrieve food during the reproduction season, as instinctual, and often forget that penguins find one reproductive partner and reproduce with them until they die. This could be considered intelligence because they are able to keep the population at great numbers. Penguins are also capable of being trained, just in rare cases where anyone tries. Penguins are also more intelligent because of their habitat choice. They do not move around because it is the best time of year and area where they are to raise the baby chicks. With more human interaction, penguins may be seen as more intelligent because humans could relate to their environment. However, because we do not live in Antarctica it is hard to understand why penguins live the way they live and therefore we see them as instinctual animals. Therefore, it depends on the humans experience with the animal, and their understanding of the species environment, that classifies an animal’s level of intelligence.
In many ways killer whales are more intelligent and adapting than emperor penguins. However, the only reason we believe this is due to the interaction we have with them. Neither animal is genetically more intelligent or capable of higher intelligence than the other. It is important to understand the environment that each species lives in to truly understand their actions. Penguins may seem less intelligent, but it is hard to fully know why unless we lived in Antarctica and experienced the conditions in which they live. We do not live in the ocean either; however, killer whales have been able to be studied in captivity, in places that are made to resemble ocean conditions. Therefore, although an animal can do more tricks or relate to humans more, the only reason some are classified as more intelligent, is due to the human response and they way humans interact with each species.
Works Cited
Ward, Paul. “Killer Whales” Cool Antarctica. 2001. 7 Nov 2008. <http://www.coolantarctica.com/antarctica%20fact%20file/whales/orcas.html>
Sea World. “Killer Whales”. Infobook. 2002. 7 Nov 2008. <http://www.seaworld.org/infobooks/killerwhale/dietkw.html>
Photo by Bill Curtsinger

4 comments:
I found it interesting that you chose to do a predator vs. prey take between your two animals. I believe it added emphasis on your topic, which added to the entire content of your essay. Good write =)
It was nice to see you use a different animal besides a dolphin. Very interested writing and good job.
I really liked your topic!! the picture SO CUTE!! very well written i enjoyed it!
I liked your choice in animals. Your idea dealing with human interaction guiding how humans see a certain animal, I totally agree with. My paper had to do with the same idea. good write.
Post a Comment